3M AFFF Settlement Court Orders: What CMO 39 and CMO 40 Require
Updated November 9, 2026. The day after 3M signed its up-to-$7.35 billion personal-injury settlement, Judge Richard M. Gergel entered two orders that set the rules for everyone with a PFAS injury claim against 3M. CMO 39 decides who is on the settlement list. CMO 40 sets what anyone who keeps suing 3M must produce, and by when. This page walks through both, for claimants and for counsel.
Which part applies to you?
What your lawyer must do by November 13 and in the two weeks after.
How claims dismissed without prejudice are handled.
What CMO 40 requires and how fast.
Every obligation, deadline and source in one list.
Key Takeaways
- CMO 39 requires lawyers to identify every eligible client to the court by November 13, 2026, filed or not. People without a lawyer can self-identify only if they already have a 3M injury case in the MDL
- Identified clients without a pending case must be filed in the MDL within 10 days after November 13, and fact sheets are due within 14 days. Fact sheets submitted after November 3 are binding
- After estimates issue, every identified claimant must choose: participate, decline and stop, or decline and keep litigating. Not responding leads toward dismissal with prejudice
- CMO 40 covers anyone who keeps suing 3M or files on or after November 4: records in 60 days, expert reports in 120 days, and dismissal with prejudice after a 30-day cure, absent good cause
- Drinking-water claims need a separate fate and transport expert, and job-related exposure entirely after 2002 needs proof that 3M's AFFF was used
- CMO 40 stays injury claims against 3M only and lasts at least 9 years. Claims against other defendants are not stayed
The two orders side by side
CMO 39: getting on the settlement list
The settlement is opt-in, so the first job is to find everyone who could opt in. CMO 39 requires every lawyer with a PFAS personal-injury client to identify all eligible clients to the court by November 13, 2026, the "ID Order Response Date." Responses go through the AFFF MDL Personal Injury Portal run by the Claims Administrator.
Who counts. An eligible claimant is anyone with a PFAS personal-injury claim for one of the six eligible injuries (kidney, testicular, liver or thyroid cancer, ulcerative colitis, or thyroid disease), "regardless of whether the Claims have been filed or served in this Court or any other court, or have been tolled or dismissed without prejudice." A claim dismissed with prejudice before the November 3 settlement date does not count.
Identification is not a decision to join. The order says it "serves only to help the Court identify Eligible Claimants, whether they ultimately elect to participate or not." Lawyers are told to read the duty "expansively" and, when unsure, to "err on the side of over-identification."
The four ways a claimant gets on the list
Filed by
The lawyer of record, or the lawyer with an active retainer and current attorney-client relationship
Who goes on it
Every eligible client, filed or unfiled, including clients whose cases were dismissed without prejudice and who are still represented
CMO 39 II.A.1, IV.A
Filed by
A lawyer who has stopped representing the client
Who goes on it
Clients whose cases were dismissed without prejudice and whom the lawyer no longer represents
CMO 39 II.A.2, II.E
Filed by
The claimant
Who goes on it
Only people already representing themselves in a personal-injury case against 3M for an eligible injury in the MDL
CMO 39 IV.C
Filed by
3M (optional)
Who goes on it
Eligible claimants with cases outside the MDL to whom 3M plans to offer the settlement, when their own lawyers do not submit a declaration
CMO 39 IV.D
What each response contains. For every client on a Primary Counsel Declaration: full name, date of birth, Social Security number, counsel and Portal ID; any derivative claimants, such as a spouse; filing status, court and case number; and the injuries alleged, the diagnosis dates and the exposure alleged. For clients who have never filed anywhere, the lawyer must also give the date the retainer agreement was signed, and the Settlement Administrator may ask for the agreement itself.
One lawyer per claimant. Each claimant should have a single Primary Counsel. Co-counsel are told to agree on one; if they have not agreed by November 13, every firm must act as Primary Counsel for the deadline, and duplicates are sorted out afterward.
No one is added after the deadline by default. The agreement says a lawyer may not amend a response "to include any plaintiff who retained the PI Counsel after the ID Order Response Date," and eligible claimants not on the final list "may participate in the Settlement only if the NPC and 3M both consent."
If your earlier case was dismissed without prejudice
The court has "dismissed thousands of claims brought by plaintiffs who failed to comply with the Court's prior orders," many of them without prejudice, which generally allows a claim to be refiled. CMO 39 treats those claimants as eligible, but adds conditions. A lawyer who still represents one can list them as a current client only by certifying all three of the following:
- The lawyer has spoken to the client since the order was issued on November 4, 2026
- Since then, the client has confirmed they will produce all information required by court order or the settlement process
- The lawyer has conducted a diligent investigation of the client's claims since the dismissal
A lawyer who cannot make those certifications may withdraw and list the client on a Disengaged Counsel Declaration, which carries identity and case information but no claim details. Clients who stay on a Primary Counsel Declaration must be refiled in the MDL within 10 days after November 13, and they must use the court's standard direct-filing process under CMO 3, not the simplified CMO 35 options.
CMO 39 II.A, II.E, II.F, III.A.2
The two weeks after November 13
File within 10 days. Any identified client on a Primary Counsel Declaration who does not have a case before the MDL court must be filed there "within ten (10) days of the ID Order Response Date." That includes unfiled clients and clients whose cases were dismissed without prejudice. It does not apply to claimants who already have a case pending outside the MDL as of November 4 or who appear on 3M's own list. Unfiled clients who were never covered by CMO 35's earlier filing requirement can use its direct-filing, multi-plaintiff bundling and short form complaint options until the same 10-day mark.
Fact sheet within 14 days. Anyone identified on a Primary Counsel or Pro Se Declaration who has not already submitted a Plaintiff Profile Form or an Amended Personal Injury Plaintiff Fact Sheet must submit the fact sheet "within fourteen (14) days of the ID Order Response Date." It must be "materially complete" and signed by the plaintiff on a date after November 13.
The fact sheet locks in the claim. Claimants who submit a fact sheet after November 3 "are bound by the information provided" and "may not make additional substantive allegations as to either Eligible Injury/ies or exposure" in a later claim package if they join, though they "may correct good faith mistakes."
CMO 39 III.A, III.B; MSA 2.3.3, 2.3.4
From the list to a decision: the claims steps
The settlement agreement sets each step in days, not calendar dates, and the Claims Administrator posts the key date for estimates on the Portal. For the money itself, see our settlement breakdown.
- 1 Initial ID Order Report Within 15 days after November 13
The Claims Administrator compiles every identification response into one list and works with the parties to fix good-faith errors and find missing claimants.
MSA 12.2.1.2
- 2 De-Duplicated ID Order Report Within 21 days of the initial report
Claimants listed by more than one law firm are resolved, with referral to the CMO 38 special master when needed.
MSA 12.2.1.3
- 3 Challenges Within 15 days of the de-duplicated report
3M or plaintiffs' negotiating counsel can challenge who is on, or missing from, the list. The Settlement Special Master decides, and the decision is final.
MSA 2.6.4 to 2.6.6
- 4 Final ID Order Report Within 40 days of the de-duplicated report
The final list of known eligible claimants. Being on it does not guarantee an award.
MSA 12.2.1.4, 3.2.6
- 5 Estimated Allocation Tables Within 28 days of the final report
Each claimant gets an estimate through the Portal. It assumes only the main payment and 100% participation, and it is not a guarantee of payment. The issue date is posted on the Portal and can be extended.
MSA 3.1, 3.1.2, 4.8
- 6 Registration (the election) 98 days after estimates issue, plus a 28-day cure period
Every claimant must choose one of three options. Anyone who misses the 98-day mark is notified and gets 28 more days, so the final cutoff, the Initial Registration Date, is 126 days after estimates issue.
MSA 3.2, 3.3
- 7 Claim Package 126 days after estimates issue
Only claimants who chose to participate submit a claim package, which is scored to set the award. Deficiencies get a notice and 28 days to cure.
MSA 4.1, 4.2, 4.2.2.2
The four places every claimant ends up
Requires
A signed release, plus a stipulated dismissal with prejudice signed by counsel
What happens next
Submits a claim package. The choice is binding and cannot be withdrawn without the consent of both 3M and plaintiffs' negotiating counsel.
MSA 3.2.1.1, 3.2.4
Requires
A stipulated dismissal with prejudice
What happens next
No award. Can switch to participating before the Initial Registration Date, or later only with both sides' agreement.
MSA 3.2.1.2, 3.4.1
Requires
The election form only
What happens next
Becomes a Litigating Plaintiff under CMO 40. Can switch to participating before the Initial Registration Date, or later only with both sides' agreement.
MSA 3.2.1.3, 3.4.2; CMO 40 1(a)
Requires
Nothing submitted
What happens next
Within 7 days after the Initial Registration Date, the list goes to the court, and 3M and plaintiffs' negotiating counsel jointly ask the court to order these plaintiffs to show cause why their claims should not be dismissed with prejudice. A non-responder who never filed faces dismissal with prejudice if they ever file in the MDL.
MSA 3.2.1.4, 3.3.3
The deal itself can still fall apart: 3M and plaintiffs' negotiating counsel each have termination rights tied to sealed participation thresholds. If the deal is terminated and follow-up mediation fails, the signed releases and dismissals are destroyed. Details are in our settlement breakdown.
CMO 40: the rules for anyone who keeps suing 3M
3M's announcement promised "an anticipated MDL court order establishing evidentiary and timing requirements for plaintiffs who may seek to litigate in the future." CMO 40 is that order. It applies to two groups, which it calls Litigating Plaintiffs: identified claimants who neither join the settlement nor take a dismissal, and anyone whose PFAS personal-injury case "of any nature" against 3M is filed in, refiled in, removed to or transferred to the MDL on or after November 4, 2026. That second group is not limited to the six eligible injuries.
The obligations are "personal and binding on the individual Litigating Plaintiffs regardless of their use of counsel or subsequent changes in representation," and they apply to people representing themselves. Everything except complaints is served on 3M through the AFFF MDL Portal.
File an amended or single-plaintiff complaint that meets the order's pleading rules, counted from the decision not to settle or from the case's arrival in the MDL.
CMO 40 16, 17
Records, the fact sheet supplement, the statute of limitations declaration, a choice-of-law statement and counsel's declaration.
CMO 40 19, 23, 33
General and specific causation, plus a fate and transport report for drinking-water and property claims.
CMO 40 27, 28
After notice of a deficiency and 30 days to cure, the court, absent good cause, will dismiss with prejudice on 3M's motion.
CMO 40 25, 32
What the complaint must say
Every Litigating Plaintiff's complaint must plead the injury, the date of diagnosis and the circumstances of exposure, including the dates and duration of exposure, the route (drinking water with the public water system's PWSID, a private well, or job-related or skin contact), and, for job-related exposure, the employer and the nature and length of the job. Plaintiffs whose existing complaint falls short get leave to amend "solely for this purpose," with no new claims or damages, within 30 days of deciding not to settle. Plaintiffs in multi-plaintiff complaints may refile on their own within the same window, and a timely refiling relates back to the original filing to the extent the law allows.
CMO 40 15 to 18
What must be produced within 60 days
Fact sheets Everyone
- •Every fact sheet required by CMOs 5, 5G and 31, fully completed
- •The 3M Litigating Personal Injury Plaintiff Fact Sheet Supplement (Exhibit A), signed under penalty of perjury
- •The Supplement asks for prior legal names and nicknames, the original filing date, start and end months for every address and exposure location, the public water system ID (PWSID) for each address or "Not A Public Water System," diagnosis dates, and page references to the medical records that establish each injury
- •Verified fact sheet answers are treated as judicial admissions unless the court allows them to be withdrawn or amended
CMO 40 23a; Exhibit A
Medical records Everyone
- •Full and complete medical records establishing the alleged injury
- •All records of diagnosis, testing and treatment for any condition claimed to be caused by PFAS
CMO 40 23b
Pharmacy records Everyone
- •Pharmacy and medical records of prescriptions and samples dispensed for the claimed condition, reaching back 10 years before diagnosis
CMO 40 23c
Employment and military records Anyone claiming exposure through military service, firefighting (paid or volunteer) or other work
- •Military personnel records, including the DD214 and enlistment records, or proof they have been requested
- •Employment records showing the job, duties and dates, such as W-2s, tax returns, pay stubs and employer verification
- •Records of all training involving AFFF or other PFAS products
- •Records of the turnout gear used, including product identification, and records from whoever bought or issued it if the claim rests on turnout gear
- •Relevant photographs and recordings, including social media posts
- •A signed declaration giving the first date, last date and date ranges of exposure
- •If all job-related AFFF exposure happened after 2002, the documents the plaintiff has showing that 3M's brand of AFFF was used
CMO 40 23d
Water records Anyone claiming drinking-water exposure
- •Proof of being at a home, facility or other site served by a contaminated water source before diagnosis, such as a water utility record, utility bill or property deed
- •For a private well, testing records showing PFAS in that well
CMO 40 23e
Death, marriage and probate records Wrongful death and loss of consortium claims
- •Marriage and death records, and proof of authority to act for the decedent or estate
CMO 40 23f
Property records Anyone also claiming property damage
- •Ownership, appraisal, tax, inspection, repair and remediation records, including records held by contractors, insurers, realtors and lenders
CMO 40 23g
Other records Everyone
- •Any other documents about PFAS exposure, including PFAS test results from any public or private entity
- •Any other documents about the injury, including relevant photos, recordings and social media posts
- •Non-privileged communications about the exposure, injury, damages or supporting facts
CMO 40 23h to 23j
Filings and declarations Everyone
- •A choice-of-law statement identifying the law and home district that should apply, unless already in the complaint, filed in the individual case and served on 3M
- •A declaration from counsel that the fact sheets are complete, the production complies, and counsel has met with the plaintiff and given them a copy of the order
- •The statute of limitations declaration (Exhibit B), signed by the plaintiff under penalty of perjury
CMO 40 23k, 23l, 33
How the records must be collected
- •The duty is the plaintiff's, and it reaches records held by doctors, employers and other third parties
- •Records are collected with authorizations or, when those are too slow or not enough, with third-party subpoenas asking for production within 30 days
- •Handing 3M signed HIPAA authorizations does not satisfy the requirement for records not yet obtained
- •Plaintiffs without a lawyer must ask the court to issue subpoenas
- •Subpoenas, records received and any "no records" statements must also be produced to 3M
- •Documents that should have been produced under the order cannot later be used in a motion or at trial
CMO 40 20 to 22, 24, 26
Expert reports within 120 days
- •Reports must meet Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26 and support both general causation and specific causation for the plaintiff's own disease or condition
- •Property damage claims need reports on causation and damages for that property, describing any inspection or testing
- •Reports must describe any examination of the plaintiff and include the complete set of records the expert relied on
- •Drinking-water and property claims also need a fate and transport report showing the probable source or sources of PFAS and how it traveled into the plaintiff's water supply or property
- •Each expert must be retained for that plaintiff's case and be willing and able to testify at deposition and trial
- •Form or template reports are not permitted and will be stricken, and experts must disclose any use of generative AI
- •3M does not waive any objection by not flagging a defect, and can raise it later
CMO 40 27 to 32
The statute of limitations declaration
Due within the 60-day Production Period, sworn under penalty of perjury, and "personal to the individual Litigating Plaintiff," covering every lawyer they have had. It asks for:
- Each injury the plaintiff says PFAS caused
- The date each injury was diagnosed
- The date the plaintiff first learned the injury may be related to PFAS
- How the plaintiff first learned that
- The date the plaintiff first spoke to or corresponded with any attorney about PFAS litigation
- The date the plaintiff first retained any counsel to investigate a PFAS claim
- The date the plaintiff first spoke to or corresponded with their current counsel
- The date the plaintiff first retained their current counsel
- The date the plaintiff first used, handled, stored, disposed of or was near AFFF, if applicable
- The date the plaintiff first saw any documents, advertisements or packaging about PFAS, with a description
CMO 40 33, 34; Exhibit B
Cases filed after November 13
For a case filed, refiled, removed or transferred after the ID Order Response Date that was not on an identification response, counsel must serve a certification within the Production Period stating:
- •The plaintiff had not retained counsel as of or before November 4, 2026, the date of the Identification Order
- •The date counsel was first retained
- •Counsel did not intentionally delay being retained for any reason, including to avoid the settlement's deadlines
Plaintiffs who were identified under CMO 39 do not need this certification.
CMO 40 39, 40
The stay, and what comes next
Apart from these procedures, "all proceedings in this MDL in cases asserting a personal injury claim against 3M are hereby stayed as to 3M," including cases filed later. Litigating Plaintiffs' other discovery against 3M stays on hold until they comply and the court orders further proceedings. The stay "does not apply to any claims asserted against any other defendants," and the court may sever stayed claims against 3M so claims against other defendants can move forward.
Within 45 days after the settlement's termination rights are used up or waived, 3M and plaintiffs' co-lead counsel will report to the court privately on the status of any Litigating Plaintiffs' claims. The court said it will not set schedules that conflict with carrying out the settlement, and that future bellwether planning will account for 3M's settlements "and the need to address and resolve claims as to various other parties in this MDL." The order "will remain in effect for at least 9 years." Under the settlement agreement, 3M owes nothing from the $680 million Reserve Fund if CMO 40 is no longer in effect.
CMO 40 12, 35 to 38, 41 to 43; MSA 11.5.1
If you were never identified
Joining later. An eligible claimant who is not on the Final ID Order Report can join the settlement only if both 3M and plaintiffs' negotiating counsel consent.
Suing 3M. A new PFAS personal-injury case against 3M that reaches the MDL falls under CMO 40, whatever the injury, with its 60-day and 120-day requirements. If it is filed after November 13 and the plaintiff was not identified, the lawyer must also certify when they were retained.
Other defendants. Neither order settles or stays claims against DuPont, Chemours, Corteva or any other AFFF defendant.
Timing. Filing deadlines are set by state law and vary. CMO 40's sworn declaration asks when a plaintiff first learned their injury might be linked to PFAS and when they first spoke to a lawyer, so those dates matter. A licensed attorney can evaluate a specific situation.
Counsel checklist
Every obligation in CMO 39, CMO 40 and the settlement agreement's registration steps, with its deadline and source. Days after estimates are counted from the Estimated Allocation Issuance Date posted on the Portal.
Identification (CMO 39)
-
Register every personal-injury plaintiff on the AFFF MDL Portal
Ongoing · CMO 39 II.B; CMO 31 I.C
-
Submit a Primary Counsel Declaration listing every eligible client, filed or unfiled
November 13, 2026 · CMO 39 II.A.1, II.B
-
Submit a Disengaged Counsel Declaration for clients dismissed without prejudice whom you no longer represent
November 13, 2026 · CMO 39 II.A.2, II.E
-
For clients dismissed without prejudice whom you still represent, make the three certifications on the Primary Counsel Declaration
November 13, 2026 · CMO 39 II.F
-
For never-filed clients, report the retainer date; produce the retainer agreement if the Settlement Administrator asks
With the declaration; on request · CMO 39 II.D.1.b, III.A.3
-
Agree on one Primary Counsel with any co-counsel; without agreement, every firm acts as Primary Counsel
November 13, 2026 · CMO 39 IV.A.3
-
Counsel who represents only a derivative claimant submits its own response
November 13, 2026 · CMO 39 IV.E
After identification (CMO 39)
-
File unfiled and dismissed-without-prejudice identified clients in the MDL (not required for cases already pending outside the MDL or claimants on 3M's list)
10 days after November 13 · CMO 39 III.A
-
CMO 35 direct filing, bundling and short form complaint are available only for unfiled clients CMO 35's filing requirement did not cover; dismissed-without-prejudice clients must direct file under CMO 3
Allowance ends 10 days after November 13 · CMO 39 III.A.1, III.A.2
-
Submit an Amended Personal Injury Plaintiff Fact Sheet for identified claimants without a Plaintiff Profile Form or Amended PFS, signed after November 13
14 days after November 13 · CMO 39 III.B
Registration (MSA)
-
Submit each client's election form, with a release and stipulated dismissal where required
98 days after estimates issue, plus 28-day cure · MSA 3.2, 3.3
-
Submit complete claim packages for participating clients; cure deficiencies within 28 days of notice
126 days after estimates issue · MSA 4.2, 4.2.2.2
Litigating Plaintiffs (CMO 40)
-
File an amended or single-plaintiff complaint that meets the pleading rules
30 days after the election or arrival in the MDL · CMO 40 15 to 17
-
Serve the production, PFS Supplement, choice-of-law statement, counsel declaration and SOL Declaration through the Portal
60 days · CMO 40 19, 23, 33
-
For cases filed after November 13 and not identified, serve the retention certification
60 days · CMO 40 39
-
Serve case-specific expert reports, including fate and transport where required
120 days · CMO 40 27 to 30
-
Cure any noticed deficiency
30 days after notice · CMO 40 25, 32
Terms used in the orders
- Eligible Claimant
- Someone with a PFAS personal-injury claim for an eligible injury, whether or not the claim was filed, served, tolled or dismissed without prejudice. A claim dismissed with prejudice before November 3, 2026 does not count.
- Eligible Injury
- Kidney cancer, testicular cancer, liver cancer, thyroid cancer, ulcerative colitis or thyroid disease.
- Primary Counsel
- The lawyer of record, or the lawyer with an active retainer and current attorney-client relationship. Each claimant should have only one.
- DWOP Plaintiff
- An eligible claimant whose case was dismissed without prejudice, often during the court's 2026 vetting of claims.
- Disengaged Counsel
- A lawyer who no longer represents a DWOP Plaintiff and lists them on a separate declaration.
- Pro Se Eligible Claimant
- Someone representing themselves in a personal-injury case against 3M for an eligible injury in the MDL.
- ID Order Response Date
- November 13, 2026, the deadline to identify eligible claimants.
- Portal
- The AFFF MDL Personal Injury Portal, run by the Claims Administrator, where declarations, fact sheets and CMO 40 materials are submitted.
- Final ID Order Report
- The Claims Administrator's final list of known eligible claimants.
- Estimated Allocation Tables
- The estimate each claimant receives before deciding. Not a guarantee of payment.
- Initial Registration Date
- The final election deadline, 126 days after estimates issue.
- Litigating Plaintiff
- Anyone pursuing a PFAS personal-injury claim against 3M under CMO 40.
- Production Period
- The 60 days a Litigating Plaintiff has to produce records and declarations.
- Fate and transport report
- An expert report tracing the probable source of PFAS and how it traveled into the plaintiff's water supply or property.
Frequently asked questions
What is CMO 39 in the AFFF MDL?
What is CMO 40 in the AFFF MDL?
Can I put myself on the 3M settlement list without a lawyer?
My AFFF case was dismissed without prejudice. Am I still eligible?
What happens after the November 13 identification deadline?
Can I change my fact sheet later?
What happens if I do not respond after I receive my estimate?
What records do I need to keep suing 3M under CMO 40?
What is a fate and transport expert report?
Do CMO 39 and CMO 40 affect claims against DuPont, Chemours or other defendants?
Related pages
Sources & References
4 sources cited- • Case Management Order No. 39 (Identification Order). In re: Aqueous Film-Forming Foams Products Liability Litigation, MDL No. 2:18-mn-2873-RMG (D.S.C. Nov. 4, 2026), ECF No. 11962.
- • Case Management Order No. 40, with Exhibit A (3M Litigating Personal Injury Plaintiff Fact Sheet Supplement) and Exhibit B (Statute of Limitations Declaration). MDL No. 2:18-mn-2873-RMG (D.S.C. Nov. 4, 2026), ECF No. 11964.
- • Master Settlement Agreement between 3M Company and the Negotiating Plaintiffs' Counsel. Dated November 3, 2026, filed as Exhibit 10.1 to 3M's Form 8-K.
- • Earlier case management orders referenced by CMO 39 and CMO 40. CMO 3 (ECF No. 72, direct filing); CMO 31 (ECF No. 6255, Portal registration); CMO 35 (ECF No. 7823, Aug. 15, 2025); CMO 37 (ECF No. 8876, Feb. 25, 2026); CMO 38 (ECF No. 9598, June 3, 2026).
Section and paragraph references (for example "CMO 40 23e" or "MSA 3.3") point to the numbered paragraphs of each order and the sections of the settlement agreement. Court orders are linked to their PACER copies in the free CourtListener RECAP archive.
Attorney Advertising. The information on this page is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is created by accessing or using this content.
Every case is unique, and results depend on the specific facts and circumstances involved. Past settlement amounts and case outcomes do not guarantee similar results in your case. If you believe you have a legal claim, you should consult with a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction who can evaluate your specific situation.